Best Payroll Services for 2023

Payroll services are essential for small businesses as they handle various payroll tasks such as calculating wages, deducting taxes, issuing payments, and filing tax forms. These services provide several benefits, including accuracy, compliance, time-saving, and automation. By outsourcing payroll tasks, small businesses can focus on their core operations while ensuring payroll tasks are handled efficiently.

Importance of Payroll Services

What is a payroll service?

A payroll service is a company or software that handles various payroll tasks on behalf of other businesses. These tasks include calculating employee wages, deducting taxes, generating pay stubs, processing direct deposits or checks, managing benefits and deductions, filing tax forms, and staying compliant with payroll regulations. Payroll services aim to streamline the payroll process, ensuring accuracy and compliance while saving time and resources for businesses.

How Much Does a Payroll Service Cost?

The cost of a payroll service can vary depending on several factors such as the size of your business, the number of employees, the frequency of pay runs, and the features and services included. Some payroll services charge a flat monthly fee, while others may have a base fee plus an additional fee per employee. It’s important to carefully review the pricing structure of different services to understand how costs will scale as your business grows.

Main Features and Factors to Consider:

When choosing a payroll service, it’s important to consider pricing, features, support, integrations, and reviews. Pricing models can vary, including flat monthly fees, per-employee fees, or fees based on the number of pay runs. The features offered by a payroll service can range from basic payroll processing to additional functionalities like tax filing, benefits administration, time tracking, and employee self-service. It’s crucial to evaluate whether the service integrates well with existing software and systems. Reliable customer support and positive reviews are also important factors to consider.

7 BestPayroll Service Softawre

Gusto: Best Overall Payroll Service

Gusto is a comprehensive payroll service popular among small businesses. It offers features such as automatic tax filing, benefits administration, contractor payments, time tracking, and employee self-service. Gusto is known for its ease of use, affordability, and reliable customer support. However, its international coverage is limited.

OnPay: Best for Unlimited Monthly Pay Runs

OnPay is a simple and affordable payroll service that allows unlimited monthly pay runs for any pay schedule. It offers features like tax filing and compliance, benefits administration, contractor payments, and integrations with accounting and HR software. OnPay provides flexibility and transparency, but lacks some advanced features.

Paychex Flex: Best for Internationally Expanding Companies

Paychex Flex is a robust and scalable payroll service suitable for businesses with international operations and growth plans. It supports multi-country payroll, tax filing and compliance, benefits administration, time and attendance, and HR outsourcing. Paychex Flex offers customization and strong security, but its complexity may require additional training.

QuickBooks Payroll: Best for QuickBooks Online Users

QuickBooks Payroll is a convenient payroll service integrated with QuickBooks Online accounting software. Its features include automatic tax filing, health benefits, contractor payments, time tracking, and live expert support. QuickBooks Payroll provides compatibility and automation, but it may have limited functionality compared to standalone payroll services.

Rippling: Easiest to Use Payroll Service

Rippling is a user-friendly and modern payroll service that automates payroll and HR tasks in one platform. Its features include tax filing and compliance, benefits administration, contractor payments, employee onboarding and offboarding, and integrations with other software. Rippling offers simplicity and efficiency, but pricing may vary based on features.

TriNet: Best for Companies that Issue Work Visas

TriNet is a professional employer organization (PEO) providing payroll and HR services for small businesses that hire foreign workers or issue work visas. Its features include tax filing and compliance, benefits administration, immigration services, risk management, and HR consulting. TriNet offers expertise and compliance support, but the cost may be higher than standalone payroll services.

Workday: Best for Global but Centralized Payroll Reporting

Workday is a cloud-based ERP software offering payroll services for global businesses that require centralized reporting and analytics. Its features include multi-country payroll, tax filing and compliance, benefits administration, time tracking, and workforce planning. Workday provides integration and scalability, but its complexity may require advanced training.

How Do I Choose the Best Payroll Service For My Business?

To choose the best payroll service for your business, consider the following factors:

  • Size and complexity of your payroll: Assess the size of your workforce, the frequency of pay runs, and any specific payroll complexities you may have, such as multiple locations or different pay structures.
  • Features and services: Determine the payroll features and services that are crucial for your business. This could include tax filing, benefits administration, time tracking, employee self-service, or integration with other software systems.
  • Compatibility and integration: Evaluate whether the payroll service integrates well with your existing software and systems, such as accounting or HR software. Seamless integration can enhance efficiency and streamline processes.
  • Reliability and security: Look for a payroll service with a proven track record of reliability and security. Payroll involves sensitive employee data, so data protection and security measures are paramount.
  • Customer support and reviews: Research the customer support reputation of the payroll service provider. Read reviews and seek recommendations from other businesses to assess the quality of their support and service.
  • Pricing and value: Compare the pricing models of different payroll services and assess the value they provide based on their features, support, and overall suitability for your business. Consider both short-term and long-term costs.

By considering these factors and conducting thorough research, you can choose a payroll service that meets your business needs, budget, and preferences.

Drawbacks of using a payroll service:

  • Loss of control: By outsourcing payroll tasks to a third-party service, you may lose some control and visibility over the process. It’s important to choose a reputable and trustworthy service provider to mitigate this concern.
  • Additional costs: Some payroll services may have hidden fees or variable pricing structures that can result in unexpected costs. It’s essential to thoroughly review the pricing structure and understand any additional charges that may apply.
  • Technical issues: Payroll services rely on software and technology, and there is always a possibility of encountering technical glitches or downtime. It’s important to assess the reliability and track record of the service provider to minimize the risk of disruptions.
  • Customer service and support: If you encounter issues or have questions regarding your payroll, the quality of customer service and support provided by the payroll service can significantly impact your experience. It’s advisable to choose a service that offers responsive and reliable support.


Choosing the best payroll service for your business depends on your specific needs, budget, and preferences. Based on the features, benefits, and value, Gusto is recommended as the best overall payroll service for most small businesses. However, it’s important to compare different services and consider the criteria mentioned earlier.



No comments yet. Why don’t you start the discussion?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *